They were told to leave by Ukraine. Some people are taking the warning seriously as Russia advances and the cost rises.


The government issued an order to residents to leave the Donetsk region as they prepare for fall and winter and fear that many there may not have access to heating, electricity, or even clean water.


A small child waves goodbye to her grandparents as the evacuation train leaves Pokrovsk on Tuesday in the Donetsk region of eastern Ukraine while holding her puppy.

AP Photo/David Goldman
By Yuliya Talmazan and Daryna Mayer

Ukraine’s KYIV As winter draws closer, leave immediately or endure the pain of a Russian assault: That is the stern warning Ukraine sent to the thousands of civilians who are still present in Donetsk, the eastern region that is currently at the center of the nation’s struggle for existence.

Every Russian shell’s thud can help some people make their decision easier. Others still find it incomprehensible to consider perhaps permanently abandoning their homes.

In the little village of Pavlivka, just a few kilometers from what are currently the front lines of the conflicts in the industrial heartland of eastern Ukraine, Lyudmyla Bogomolova was born and reared.

The math teacher has been assisting in the distribution of humanitarian aid to those in need in her area ever since Russia invaded in February. But the shelling has been unbearable because Moscow’s might is concentrated on a move to seize total control of her home province.

The first time Bogomolova, 51, and her husband, Mykola, considered leaving was last month, the woman told NBC News over the phone.
She explained that the intense shelling was making it impossible to stay, her voice tinged with sadness and anxiety. The overwhelming fear simply persisted.

After that, a rocket attack on their community on July 24 left According to Bogomolova, Mykola, 54, had completely smashed the bone and joint in his left hand. They were already decided.

Well, I’d better get out of here,” she remarked.

Bogomolova is one of the more than 200,000 civilians in Donetsk who the Ukrainian government is attempting to evacuate as soon as possible. She is presently in Kurakhove, where Mykola is receiving medical treatment for his wounds.

The Donbas region, which includes the province and the nearby city of Luhansk, is the focus of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s ongoing battle. Since taking over Luhansk last month, Russia has been making a brutal advance on Donetsk. Control of both would grant the Kremlin a significant triumph and open the potential that it may conclude the war by severing off a sizable and vital portion of its neighbors’ territory.

More than two-thirds of the civilian population in the Donetsk province has already evacuated, but according to local officials, the estimated 350,000 civilians who are still there face a humanitarian crisis as the colder season approaches in addition to the threat of an escalating Russian onslaught.

Zelenskyy stated in a July 30 video address that the more people who leave the Donetsk region immediately, the less time the Russian army will have to slaughter civilians.

According to the nation’s vice prime minister, Iryna Vereshchuk, warned last week, persistent Russian military attacks on civilian infrastructure have left the region without a gas supply, and electricity and water supplies are in jeopardy ahead of winter.

That is similar to what occurred earlier in the battle in the port city of Mariupol, which is located in the Donetsk province.

More than 1,100 people have been relocated from cities and villages in the Donetsk province towards primarily central Ukraine since the government-mandated evacuations started this week, according to the government said.

Despite the warnings and the fact that they now have to disclose the hazards of staying, Ukrainian officials still acknowledge that many people are refusing to leave.

One of them is Marina, who requested that her last name not be used due to concerns about her safety.

Despite having the opportunity to flee to Kyiv or even western Ukraine, far from the area of active combat, she chose to remain in her hometown of Kramatorsk, which is roughly 10 kilometers from the front lines.

She claimed that neither she nor other people who are motivated by hope are frightened by the idea of having to collect rainwater for drinking or use wood for heating.

She is hesitant to sign the document as well. The 60-year-old Kramatorsk resident, Marina, said she would first take some time to sit down and attentively study everything.

She continued, “I believe in God and I believe in the Ukrainian army. This is my fate.
In order to reduce civilian losses and give itself greater operational freedom, analysts say, Ukraine is eager to evacuate people out of the area.

According to Michael Clarke, a professor of war studies at Kings College London, Kyiv plans to undertake a strong defense of the important cities of Slavyansk and Kramatorsk.

According to Clarke, Ukraine’s military is expecting to launch a counteroffensive in the Russian-occupied south and is looking for a strategic triumph there. According to Clarke, any success there must not cost the remainder of the Donbas in order for it to have a political influence.

According to geopolitical and security analyst Michael A. Horowitz, head of intelligence at the consultancy Le Beck, the evacuations provide Ukrainians more freedom to defend or flee a city without having to take residents into mind.

Since the outset, Ukrainians have also urged people to flee, and Horowitz claimed that citizens have made it much harder for Ukrainian soldiers to do their jobs.

Therefore, Horowitz said, Zelensky’s directive might merely be a step up in efforts to get people out of what has grown to be the main area of conflict.

Amnesty International, a human rights organization, claimed in a study that has drawn widespread criticism that Ukrainian forces have occasionally put people at risk of Russian assaults by basing themselves in schools, homes, and other sites in populated regions.

Zelenskyy, as well as other Kyiv authorities and allies on social media, criticized the article.

In a statement, Amnesty stated that it had made it plain that the military actions by Ukraine that we had outlined could not in any way excuse Russia’s recurring transgressions of international humanitarian law.

As we did in this instance, when we discover violations of international humanitarian law, we will honestly and correctly report them. It stated that credible human rights reporting would not include ignoring abuses perpetrated by a side that was supported.

People wish to stay for a number of reasons, Oleksandr Ivanov, a volunteer working for a regional relief agency assisting with the evacuations, told NBC News.

Ivanov stated that many people are unable to leave their aging parents. It might be emotionally challenging for older individuals to leave. Of course, some people hold the opinion that they will not leave their home until a shell hits it.

According to Tetyana Ignatchenko, a spokesperson for the Donetsk Regional Military Administration who is assisting in organizing the evacuations, people in the Donetsk province are accustomed to the fighting as well. They had been residing close to the battle lines of what was a smoldering struggle between separatists backed by Russia and Ukrainian security forces since 2014.

Ignatchenko claimed that this makes them particularly afraid to leave right now. She continued that the majority of those having trouble accepting leaving for uncertainty are persons.

She continued, “However, the bombardment is persistent and unexpected and is certain to get worse as the Kremlin’s troops try to advance further.” This is due to the full-scale Russian invasion in February and the escalating Russian assault in Donetsk.

Here, she remarked, there is never a day when a civilian is not killed or hurt.
Ignatchenko continued, “This is not about spreading fear.” It’s about conveying to people the necessity of ultimately accepting personal accountability and treating this seriously.
Journalist Yuliya Talmazan lives in London.